Stephen Gandel believes that stablecoins rewards will not endanger the banking system and that estimates of deposit flight are excessive. Nonetheless, he acknowledged that the equity returns of banking institutions might be affected, as banks will be forced to pay higher interest rates.
Analyst: Bank’s Stablecoin Reward-Tied Deposit Flight Numbers Are Flawed
The discussion of stablecoin rewards in the CLARITY bill has prompted concerns from banks, which claim these rewards might endanger the credit system.
According to Bank of America’s CEO Brian Moynihan, banks could lose up to $6 trillion in deposits, as customers seek higher yields by holding stablecoins under the custody of cryptocurrency exchanges.
Stephen Gandel, a seasoned financial analyst and journalist, claims that the banks’ arguments are baseless, as there is no way to pull deposits from the system completely.
He explained:
“Cash that goes to a stablecoin doesn’t simply disappear – it goes into the reserve assets like Treasury bills or bank accounts.”
This means that whenever stablecoin issuers buy U.S. Treasuries to support their issuance, the party selling the debt instruments would have extra cash in their account. In this way, funds would just be shuffled around.
Gandel acknowledges that individual banks will have to pay more to keep savers’ cash under their control, potentially affecting their business model profitability. He alleges that raising interest levels by 1% would still allow 1,600 national banks to enjoy double-digit earnings, with the U.S. remaining the nation with the most banks even after this shift.
“The banking sector survived the advent of money market funds, even if many smaller regional lenders didn’t. And savers are much better off for it. The same may be true if stablecoins take off,” he concluded.
While stablecoins issuers have been banned from offering direct rewards to holders, third parties can still do it. Banks have qualified this as a loophole and are actively trying to plug it by including this consideration in the CLARITY Act.
Nonetheless, the bill has stalled due to a lack of compromise on this subject from both banks and the cryptocurrency industry.
FAQ
- What concerns have banks raised regarding stablecoin rewards in the CLARITY bill?
Banks argue that allowing stablecoin rewards could lead to a loss of up to $6 trillion in deposits as customers seek higher yields from cryptocurrency exchanges.
- How does financial analyst Stephen Gandel view the banks’ concerns?
Gandel claims the banks’ fears are unfounded, noting that cash moving to stablecoins does not disappear but is reallocated into assets like Treasury bills or bank accounts.
- What impact might the shift to stablecoins have on individual banks?
While banks may need to increase interest rates to retain customers, Gandel believes many national banks can still thrive, even with a 1% increase in rates.
- What is the current status of the CLARITY Act concerning stablecoin rewards?
The bill has stalled due to disagreements between banks and the cryptocurrency industry over how to manage stablecoin rewards and related loopholes.
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
US crude oil inventories for the week ending March 20 increased by 6.926 million barrels, far exceeding expectations
Gate News reported that on March 25, the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) released data showing that U.S. crude oil inventory increased by 6.926 million barrels for the week ending March 20, far exceeding market expectations of 0.477 million barrels, with the previous value at 6.156 million barrels. Crude oil inventory in Cushing, Oklahoma (the main U.S. crude oil delivery point) increased by 3.421 million barrels, with the previous value at 0.944 million barrels. Strategic Petroleum Reserve inventory remained at 0 million barrels, with the previous value at 0 million barrels.
GateNews1h ago
Dallas Federal Reserve Survey: WTI Crude Oil Price Expected to Reach $74 per Barrel by End of 2026
Gate News reports that on March 25, the Dallas Federal Reserve released an energy survey showing that respondents expect WTI crude oil (West Texas Intermediate crude oil, the U.S. crude oil benchmark price) to be priced at $74 per barrel by the end of 2026. Regarding drilling activity, 50% of respondents expect drilling numbers will not increase in 2026, while 47% of respondents expect oil well numbers will see slight or significant increases.
GateNews1h ago
Crypto Growth to Be Led by Banks, Says BNY Mellon CEO
BNY Mellon’s CEO, Robin Vince, recently stated that large banks will drive the next wave of crypto growth by linking digital assets with traditional finance. He highlighted that clearer regulations will allow banks to offer secure and reliable crypto services, making digital assets more accessible t
Coinfomania3h ago
Turkey Depletes Approximately $30 Billion in Foreign Reserves Over Three Weeks, May Mobilize Gold Reserves to Stabilize Exchange Rate
Due to deteriorating Middle East tensions, Turkey's foreign exchange reserves are declining rapidly, triggering market concerns about exchange rate stability. The central bank has deployed $30 billion to support the lira and may replenish liquidity through gold reserve sales. Rising international oil prices have exacerbated inflation and trade deficits, leaving Turkey facing pressure for currency depreciation and interest rate increases.
GateNews3h ago
Philippines Declares National Energy Emergency Due to Iran War, Global Energy Supply Under Pressure
Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos announced that the nation has entered an energy emergency state to address threats to energy supply from Middle East conflicts. Multiple countries globally that rely on imported energy have also implemented austerity measures, reflecting the fragility of energy supply chains and the impact of conflicts on international markets.
GateNews7h ago
International Energy Agency Director: Prepared to Release More Oil Reserves, Still Has 80% Inventory
International Energy Agency Director Birol stated in Tokyo that in response to surging global energy prices, it will prepare to release additional oil reserves. Previously, Japan's Prime Minister requested preparations for a second emergency release. The IEA has announced the release of 400 million barrels of oil and warned that global energy security faces severe threats.
GateNews7h ago
